Let's talk about sex.
Dec. 19th, 2006 08:05 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
truepennyETA: since ![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-community.gif)
metafandom has apparently linked to this post sans context, let me state explicitly that I'm talking about the MISLABELING of original fiction featuring a same-sex relationship--as for example, ![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
matociquala's Carnival--as slash in reviews and commentary by people who are not slash writers themselves. I'm not trying to talk about what slash writers choose to do within their fandoms and communities. Not a slasher. Don't play one on TV. I'm arguing that slash, as a term, belongs to fanfiction, and should not be applied to works that are not fanfiction. My reasons for feeling as I do, explained in the following post, stem partly from my own career as a pro writer whose work features a lot of same-sex relationships, and partly from my appreciation, as a genre theorist, of the intertextual subversion inherent in what slash does.
The subtext, as Giles says to Buffy in "Ted," is rapidly becoming text.
hth
More specifically, let's talk about slash and why it is offensive and heteronormatizing to equate it with homosexual relationships.
The subversion/containment model (proposed by Foucault and applied by a bunch of New Historicist critics in the 1980s) has buried somewhere in the unexamined assumptions of its premise the notion that somehow subversion is bad. Or nonsustainable. Conservation of energy. A society tends to conserve the status quo.
This may be descriptively true (she says, looking dourly at her own society), but prescriptively, it sucks major moose cock, because it assumes that subversion exists to be contained. Hence Natalie Zemon Davis's elaboration of Foucault with her "pressure-valve" idea. (Which, btw, I think is incredibly helpful for understanding extremely conservative societies--like I said, descriptively the idea can be very helpful.)
Slash is subversion.
(For those of you who are still wondering what on earth I'm talking about, slash is a kind of fanfiction which posits a romantic/sexual relationship between two characters who in canon have no such thing. You might also describe it as an underground movement. It's named for the labelling convention that marks it; the first slash was K/S: Kirk-slash-Spock.)
Slash says, "These two canonically romantically-uninvolved characters have a close, intense, and obviously loving relationship. Our society--as inscribed on these characters by censorship and other kinds of normatizing pressure--does not allow that relationship to be developed in a sexual way. Let's transgress the taboo."
Now, obviously, that transgression can be done mindfully or otherwise, but the key component to slash is the overt sexualization of a non-sexual, or only subtextually sexual, relationship.
That relationship is, 9 times out of 10, between two men. Because, 9 times out of 10, the most intense and interesting relationship in any given canon is--wait for it--between two men. (And that has to do with a whole bunch of other factors and influences including, you know, four or five millennia worth of patriarchy.)
Now, why am I so adamant that slash is not the same as homosexual relationships?
Because I insist that homosexual relationships ought not to be categorized as subversive.
(Okay, yes, leftist liberal commie bitch, that would be me. Please don't tell me you're surprised.)
Labelling a homosexual relationship in a work of fiction as slash is wrong for a couple of reasons. One is that it's eliding the line between a work of fiction and commentary ON that work of fiction. I think it's inherent to slash that it is subverting and deconstructing and undercutting a canon text's assumptions about sexuality and love (using "text" here in a broad and metaphorical sense, rather than the literal one of words-printed-on-a-page). Slash is a game played with canon, and part of its value is in the tension it both creates and illuminates between canon text and subtext.
The other reason that it's wrong to label homosexual relationships, whether in or out of fiction, as slash is that it is reinscribing heteronormativity on our society and our discourse. It's a syllogism. Slash is gay sex. Slash is subversive. Therefore, gay sex is subversive. The subversion/containment model is a BOX, and as long as we keep putting homosexual relationships in that box, we are reinforcing the idea that heterosexuality is the standard by which all other sexualities will and ought to be judged. The same idea that is powering the (often hysterical) attempts to define marriage in such a way that gay and lesbian people cannot have it. Because their committed monogamous relationships are being judged as subversive.
And that's so horribly wrong that it's eaten all my words.
metafandom has apparently linked to this post sans context, let me state explicitly that I'm talking about the MISLABELING of original fiction featuring a same-sex relationship--as for example, matociquala's Carnival--as slash in reviews and commentary by people who are not slash writers themselves. I'm not trying to talk about what slash writers choose to do within their fandoms and communities. Not a slasher. Don't play one on TV. I'm arguing that slash, as a term, belongs to fanfiction, and should not be applied to works that are not fanfiction. My reasons for feeling as I do, explained in the following post, stem partly from my own career as a pro writer whose work features a lot of same-sex relationships, and partly from my appreciation, as a genre theorist, of the intertextual subversion inherent in what slash does.The subtext, as Giles says to Buffy in "Ted," is rapidly becoming text.
hth
More specifically, let's talk about slash and why it is offensive and heteronormatizing to equate it with homosexual relationships.
The subversion/containment model (proposed by Foucault and applied by a bunch of New Historicist critics in the 1980s) has buried somewhere in the unexamined assumptions of its premise the notion that somehow subversion is bad. Or nonsustainable. Conservation of energy. A society tends to conserve the status quo.
This may be descriptively true (she says, looking dourly at her own society), but prescriptively, it sucks major moose cock, because it assumes that subversion exists to be contained. Hence Natalie Zemon Davis's elaboration of Foucault with her "pressure-valve" idea. (Which, btw, I think is incredibly helpful for understanding extremely conservative societies--like I said, descriptively the idea can be very helpful.)
Slash is subversion.
(For those of you who are still wondering what on earth I'm talking about, slash is a kind of fanfiction which posits a romantic/sexual relationship between two characters who in canon have no such thing. You might also describe it as an underground movement. It's named for the labelling convention that marks it; the first slash was K/S: Kirk-slash-Spock.)
Slash says, "These two canonically romantically-uninvolved characters have a close, intense, and obviously loving relationship. Our society--as inscribed on these characters by censorship and other kinds of normatizing pressure--does not allow that relationship to be developed in a sexual way. Let's transgress the taboo."
Now, obviously, that transgression can be done mindfully or otherwise, but the key component to slash is the overt sexualization of a non-sexual, or only subtextually sexual, relationship.
That relationship is, 9 times out of 10, between two men. Because, 9 times out of 10, the most intense and interesting relationship in any given canon is--wait for it--between two men. (And that has to do with a whole bunch of other factors and influences including, you know, four or five millennia worth of patriarchy.)
Now, why am I so adamant that slash is not the same as homosexual relationships?
Because I insist that homosexual relationships ought not to be categorized as subversive.
(Okay, yes, leftist liberal commie bitch, that would be me. Please don't tell me you're surprised.)
Labelling a homosexual relationship in a work of fiction as slash is wrong for a couple of reasons. One is that it's eliding the line between a work of fiction and commentary ON that work of fiction. I think it's inherent to slash that it is subverting and deconstructing and undercutting a canon text's assumptions about sexuality and love (using "text" here in a broad and metaphorical sense, rather than the literal one of words-printed-on-a-page). Slash is a game played with canon, and part of its value is in the tension it both creates and illuminates between canon text and subtext.
The other reason that it's wrong to label homosexual relationships, whether in or out of fiction, as slash is that it is reinscribing heteronormativity on our society and our discourse. It's a syllogism. Slash is gay sex. Slash is subversive. Therefore, gay sex is subversive. The subversion/containment model is a BOX, and as long as we keep putting homosexual relationships in that box, we are reinforcing the idea that heterosexuality is the standard by which all other sexualities will and ought to be judged. The same idea that is powering the (often hysterical) attempts to define marriage in such a way that gay and lesbian people cannot have it. Because their committed monogamous relationships are being judged as subversive.
And that's so horribly wrong that it's eaten all my words.
New Protrude
Date: 2016-12-10 09:54 pm (UTC)http://arab.aunties.porndairy.in/?post.eileen
telefondan joke activists deting ajman
My brand-new website
Date: 2016-12-11 07:22 pm (UTC)http://gay.adultgalls.com/?pg-uriel
gay texting gay guide gay dating site marlon brando gay big gay
Communal pictures
Date: 2016-12-11 09:34 pm (UTC)http://dickgirl.replyme.pw/?personal-aspen
xshemale transxual sex shemals free videos shemail sex shemaile sex video
Communal pictures
Date: 2016-12-12 10:57 pm (UTC)http://amateurblowjob.adultnet.in/?kendall
long island erotic vampire erotic best erotic film erotic read mobile erotic games
Sexual pictures
Date: 2016-12-13 03:41 am (UTC)http://gay.adultgalls.com/?page_gavin
gay web chat free gay dating sites gay clothing ben gay gay beijing
Adult placement
Date: 2016-12-13 10:08 am (UTC)http://asses.sexblog.pw/?pic_kendra
zoligirls pictures rapidshare sprained foot pain factory children hentai
New Protrude
Date: 2016-12-13 04:42 pm (UTC)http://hentai.sexblog.pw/?phiz_noelle
xxx tube hindi filming in china culinary school college girls kissing
Renewed site
Date: 2016-12-13 08:00 pm (UTC)http://gayfiles.xblog.in/?info_johan
gay cat gay saunas matthew morrison gay free gay cam chat gay school
My unfamiliar website
Date: 2016-12-14 05:25 am (UTC)http://asianshemales.replyme.pw/?personal-johanna
shemen tgirl shemall pictures freeshemale.com shemeal sex movies
Mod Protrude
Date: 2016-12-14 06:44 am (UTC)makeup girls world domination 2 uk vintage dresses
http://sissyblog.twiclub.in/?blog.nathalie
women in nighties bridesmaid designers femdom stories feminization 2015 skirts clitoral vibrators men for men sites cannabis seeds canada marijuana growing light
Pictures from venereal networks
Date: 2016-12-14 03:37 pm (UTC)little girls clothing old men love teen poems on women
http://feminisation.xblog.in/?read.tia
chronic feminized seeds husband sharing videos www sex gire com men younger women video with sex toys female hormone pills online learn to sing online forced feminization of husband
Pictures from venereal networks
Date: 2016-12-14 04:24 pm (UTC)http://shemaledating.sexblog.pw/?alexandrea
erotic apps victorian erotic photographs tantra erotic erotic traveller adult erotica
Pictures from community networks
Date: 2016-12-15 03:47 am (UTC)http://elite.dating.blogporn.in/?gain.jaidyn
free chinese personals free dating relationship advice phone singles 50 dating holidays for over 50s
Communal pictures
Date: 2016-12-15 08:25 am (UTC)wallpaper download wallpaper download free app stores for android theme live wallpaper android android game emulator google store play app
http://sex.games.android.porndairy.in/?profile.jaylene
android software free downloads android apk market online games army free download of google play top 10 android apps free
Pictures from collective networks
Date: 2016-12-16 03:49 am (UTC)computer games for download sexy gail androide application download free free mobile phones
http://adult.android.market.sexblog.pw/?leaf.elena
download apps on android phone hd sex wallpapers for android die beste apps sexe mp4 download download adult apk
Recent site
Date: 2016-12-17 12:19 am (UTC)http://euro.tits.epornstar.xyz/?entry.melinda
swedish public porn titi porn comics porn teen webcams brad star gay porn free video girls trombone porn
My new website
Date: 2016-12-18 03:46 pm (UTC)http://dateme.sexblog.pw/?gain.estefani
free mature women dating top online dating site meeting wealthy singles dating site for professionals canada meet black women online
Delivered grown-up galleries
Date: 2016-12-20 04:16 am (UTC)download apps on android software product development girls naked free pics sexy and adult videos apk android app
http://erotic.apps.android.blogporn.in/?register.aniya
preity zinta sexy wallpaper sexs game com android games pack dating best wallpaper girl beauty
Pictures from venereal networks
Date: 2016-12-20 11:17 am (UTC)porn comic book free play barbie makeover games sexy underwear women
http://sissytales.porndairy.in/?read.paola
dirty old gay men fucking can i buy weed seeds online princess dresses online man toy sex video sexy panties free dating sites transsexual male to female surgery barbie is games
Grown up galleries
Date: 2016-12-23 11:23 am (UTC)http://shemales.xblog.in/?blog.michelle
shemaleporn trannysex shaemle video hard core transexual sexy pics
Grown up position
Date: 2016-12-23 06:11 pm (UTC)http://asianshemales.replyme.pw/?post.eden
best shemal sex p or n sex free shemal movies freeshemalemovies.com shemeal sex movies
Grown up galleries
Date: 2016-12-24 01:26 am (UTC)http://shemale.replyme.pw/?personal.talia
free pron vidos.com shamale shemla.com free shmale sex shemails sex videos
Public pictures
Date: 2016-12-24 11:06 pm (UTC)http://fitness.sexblog.pw/?private.tristan
aloe vera fermentation homemade school of fashion find the india election result my little bastard adult swim
Full-grown galleries
Date: 2016-12-25 08:15 pm (UTC)http://sexypic.erolove.in/?entry-joanna
lezbien porn movies tube sex tamil xxx thirdmovies 7 wonders of natural world girls vidio free of school sex
Mature galleries
Date: 2016-12-26 05:15 am (UTC)http://hotties.pictures.erolove.in/?post.justice
arabian office sex hijaab 13 yr old pussy pics free milf ocmics song lyrics for rushing winds blow threw this temple xxx porn 100 free tube ethiopian