Let's talk about sex.
Dec. 19th, 2006 08:05 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
truepennyETA: since ![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-community.gif)
metafandom has apparently linked to this post sans context, let me state explicitly that I'm talking about the MISLABELING of original fiction featuring a same-sex relationship--as for example, ![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
matociquala's Carnival--as slash in reviews and commentary by people who are not slash writers themselves. I'm not trying to talk about what slash writers choose to do within their fandoms and communities. Not a slasher. Don't play one on TV. I'm arguing that slash, as a term, belongs to fanfiction, and should not be applied to works that are not fanfiction. My reasons for feeling as I do, explained in the following post, stem partly from my own career as a pro writer whose work features a lot of same-sex relationships, and partly from my appreciation, as a genre theorist, of the intertextual subversion inherent in what slash does.
The subtext, as Giles says to Buffy in "Ted," is rapidly becoming text.
hth
More specifically, let's talk about slash and why it is offensive and heteronormatizing to equate it with homosexual relationships.
The subversion/containment model (proposed by Foucault and applied by a bunch of New Historicist critics in the 1980s) has buried somewhere in the unexamined assumptions of its premise the notion that somehow subversion is bad. Or nonsustainable. Conservation of energy. A society tends to conserve the status quo.
This may be descriptively true (she says, looking dourly at her own society), but prescriptively, it sucks major moose cock, because it assumes that subversion exists to be contained. Hence Natalie Zemon Davis's elaboration of Foucault with her "pressure-valve" idea. (Which, btw, I think is incredibly helpful for understanding extremely conservative societies--like I said, descriptively the idea can be very helpful.)
Slash is subversion.
(For those of you who are still wondering what on earth I'm talking about, slash is a kind of fanfiction which posits a romantic/sexual relationship between two characters who in canon have no such thing. You might also describe it as an underground movement. It's named for the labelling convention that marks it; the first slash was K/S: Kirk-slash-Spock.)
Slash says, "These two canonically romantically-uninvolved characters have a close, intense, and obviously loving relationship. Our society--as inscribed on these characters by censorship and other kinds of normatizing pressure--does not allow that relationship to be developed in a sexual way. Let's transgress the taboo."
Now, obviously, that transgression can be done mindfully or otherwise, but the key component to slash is the overt sexualization of a non-sexual, or only subtextually sexual, relationship.
That relationship is, 9 times out of 10, between two men. Because, 9 times out of 10, the most intense and interesting relationship in any given canon is--wait for it--between two men. (And that has to do with a whole bunch of other factors and influences including, you know, four or five millennia worth of patriarchy.)
Now, why am I so adamant that slash is not the same as homosexual relationships?
Because I insist that homosexual relationships ought not to be categorized as subversive.
(Okay, yes, leftist liberal commie bitch, that would be me. Please don't tell me you're surprised.)
Labelling a homosexual relationship in a work of fiction as slash is wrong for a couple of reasons. One is that it's eliding the line between a work of fiction and commentary ON that work of fiction. I think it's inherent to slash that it is subverting and deconstructing and undercutting a canon text's assumptions about sexuality and love (using "text" here in a broad and metaphorical sense, rather than the literal one of words-printed-on-a-page). Slash is a game played with canon, and part of its value is in the tension it both creates and illuminates between canon text and subtext.
The other reason that it's wrong to label homosexual relationships, whether in or out of fiction, as slash is that it is reinscribing heteronormativity on our society and our discourse. It's a syllogism. Slash is gay sex. Slash is subversive. Therefore, gay sex is subversive. The subversion/containment model is a BOX, and as long as we keep putting homosexual relationships in that box, we are reinforcing the idea that heterosexuality is the standard by which all other sexualities will and ought to be judged. The same idea that is powering the (often hysterical) attempts to define marriage in such a way that gay and lesbian people cannot have it. Because their committed monogamous relationships are being judged as subversive.
And that's so horribly wrong that it's eaten all my words.
metafandom has apparently linked to this post sans context, let me state explicitly that I'm talking about the MISLABELING of original fiction featuring a same-sex relationship--as for example, matociquala's Carnival--as slash in reviews and commentary by people who are not slash writers themselves. I'm not trying to talk about what slash writers choose to do within their fandoms and communities. Not a slasher. Don't play one on TV. I'm arguing that slash, as a term, belongs to fanfiction, and should not be applied to works that are not fanfiction. My reasons for feeling as I do, explained in the following post, stem partly from my own career as a pro writer whose work features a lot of same-sex relationships, and partly from my appreciation, as a genre theorist, of the intertextual subversion inherent in what slash does.The subtext, as Giles says to Buffy in "Ted," is rapidly becoming text.
hth
More specifically, let's talk about slash and why it is offensive and heteronormatizing to equate it with homosexual relationships.
The subversion/containment model (proposed by Foucault and applied by a bunch of New Historicist critics in the 1980s) has buried somewhere in the unexamined assumptions of its premise the notion that somehow subversion is bad. Or nonsustainable. Conservation of energy. A society tends to conserve the status quo.
This may be descriptively true (she says, looking dourly at her own society), but prescriptively, it sucks major moose cock, because it assumes that subversion exists to be contained. Hence Natalie Zemon Davis's elaboration of Foucault with her "pressure-valve" idea. (Which, btw, I think is incredibly helpful for understanding extremely conservative societies--like I said, descriptively the idea can be very helpful.)
Slash is subversion.
(For those of you who are still wondering what on earth I'm talking about, slash is a kind of fanfiction which posits a romantic/sexual relationship between two characters who in canon have no such thing. You might also describe it as an underground movement. It's named for the labelling convention that marks it; the first slash was K/S: Kirk-slash-Spock.)
Slash says, "These two canonically romantically-uninvolved characters have a close, intense, and obviously loving relationship. Our society--as inscribed on these characters by censorship and other kinds of normatizing pressure--does not allow that relationship to be developed in a sexual way. Let's transgress the taboo."
Now, obviously, that transgression can be done mindfully or otherwise, but the key component to slash is the overt sexualization of a non-sexual, or only subtextually sexual, relationship.
That relationship is, 9 times out of 10, between two men. Because, 9 times out of 10, the most intense and interesting relationship in any given canon is--wait for it--between two men. (And that has to do with a whole bunch of other factors and influences including, you know, four or five millennia worth of patriarchy.)
Now, why am I so adamant that slash is not the same as homosexual relationships?
Because I insist that homosexual relationships ought not to be categorized as subversive.
(Okay, yes, leftist liberal commie bitch, that would be me. Please don't tell me you're surprised.)
Labelling a homosexual relationship in a work of fiction as slash is wrong for a couple of reasons. One is that it's eliding the line between a work of fiction and commentary ON that work of fiction. I think it's inherent to slash that it is subverting and deconstructing and undercutting a canon text's assumptions about sexuality and love (using "text" here in a broad and metaphorical sense, rather than the literal one of words-printed-on-a-page). Slash is a game played with canon, and part of its value is in the tension it both creates and illuminates between canon text and subtext.
The other reason that it's wrong to label homosexual relationships, whether in or out of fiction, as slash is that it is reinscribing heteronormativity on our society and our discourse. It's a syllogism. Slash is gay sex. Slash is subversive. Therefore, gay sex is subversive. The subversion/containment model is a BOX, and as long as we keep putting homosexual relationships in that box, we are reinforcing the idea that heterosexuality is the standard by which all other sexualities will and ought to be judged. The same idea that is powering the (often hysterical) attempts to define marriage in such a way that gay and lesbian people cannot have it. Because their committed monogamous relationships are being judged as subversive.
And that's so horribly wrong that it's eaten all my words.
Communal pictures
Date: 2017-04-13 08:27 pm (UTC)http://peggme.yopoint.in/?profile.kelsie
erotic mallu erotic traveller sexy chat erotic strangulation erotic reveiw
Loose matured galleries
Date: 2017-04-13 08:38 pm (UTC)sissy maid tasks women and slaves mmp 3 download
http://sissytales.porndairy.in/?view.katharine
facial plastic surgery uk feminine hygiene disposal bags slips carol burnett plastic surgery australian news this week small cock ring penis pills دانلود Ùیلم Ùیلم سوپر
Experimental Project
Date: 2017-04-13 08:40 pm (UTC)http://pattaya.girls.blogporn.in/?post.audrey
film sack maytorena alcohol liberia
Matured placement
Date: 2017-04-13 08:54 pm (UTC)http://hotties.pictures.erolove.in/?entry.denise
new teen fashions bdsm and asphyxia why do i have a black tongue waimea high school ftp animal sex
Loose full-grown galleries
Date: 2017-04-13 09:07 pm (UTC)http://eurodate.sexblog.top/?post.alexandra
just fishing dating free sites for marriage and dating gay dating sites for free dating site business girls date for free app
My unfamiliar website
Date: 2017-04-13 09:07 pm (UTC)http://best.tits.erolove.in/?entry-faith
software to keep out porn soft family porn younger teen porn videos porn movie gallery hardcore vintage porn full length
Public pictures
Date: 2017-04-13 09:29 pm (UTC)live screensavers for android games download google market for android 2 2 game download free game free games from google play
http://sexgames.android.tobuy.in/?gain.annabella
pornovideos free porn mp4 downloads android 2 3 gingerbread downkoad games apps for android free download android system application
Mod Project
Date: 2017-04-13 09:32 pm (UTC)http://asslick.photo.erolove.in/?post.kenna
infernal bondage pig 2 nice tall women naked bunny teens nude pteen burn mkv blue ray image files
Mature placement
Date: 2017-04-13 10:05 pm (UTC)gay men on gay men girls plastic pants transgender before after
http://sissies.purplesphere.in/?read.annalise
what names mean print on t shirt the unhappy marriage of marxism and feminism lace hosiery dictionary english to english meaning watch lesbians sex videos girl dress woman sex and man
My brand-new website
Date: 2017-04-13 10:13 pm (UTC)free sexy mobile video download xxx videos download videos free online adult game live video adult chat sexy download in 3gp
http://sexyapps.erolove.in/?profile.mckenna
ms word app for android mobile android app development videos free 3gpporn desktop wallpaper free downloads all applications for android
My supplementary website
Date: 2017-04-13 10:39 pm (UTC)http://jessica.casual.blogporn.in/?diagram.reilly
dating free trial russian dating sites uk aids and hiv facts filipino men dating find a love
Pictures from social networks
Date: 2017-04-13 10:47 pm (UTC)http://europe.meet.erolove.top/?gain.jasmyn
young teenage dating sites funky fish dating site webcam chat dating best dating sites in the world 2015 famous dating sites
My new website
Date: 2017-04-13 11:12 pm (UTC)icons for android apps free download mobile india price poker android app sexy photos sexy sexy free paid android apps
http://apps.android.telrock.org/?register.zoie
free mp4 music downloads top 10 apps games for android download game for android tablet download hd themes for android screensavers for android mobile
Full-grown galleries
Date: 2017-04-13 11:21 pm (UTC)http://blondesex.twiclub.in/?leaf.erica
star wars erotic online erotic novels erotic games download erotic historical romance sex sex
Pictures from collective networks
Date: 2017-04-13 11:36 pm (UTC)free download app lock office app for android mob org android games android freeware htc mobile price list india
http://pornmarket.replyme.pw/?post.alysha
photos stock android best apps get free ringtones top games apk download android browser for porn
Unencumbered galleries
Date: 2017-04-14 12:23 am (UTC)apps and android besten android app girl sexy call apps free download for android mobile android app stores
http://games.android.telrock.net/?dispatch.desiree
best free movie android app mobile rpg android live adult chat store market download iran apps apk
My supplementary website
Date: 2017-04-14 12:24 am (UTC)famous liberal feminists furniture beauty salon forced feminized men
http://sissytales.porndairy.in/?read.yvonne
cannabis seeds in usa cleaning services jobs yellow pencil skirt free girls for fucking malaysian full lace wigs sex for men and women forced to become a sissy slut pink boys clothes
Pictures from collective networks
Date: 2017-04-14 12:29 am (UTC)http://ashlynn.pornpost.in/?gain.mckenzie
social networking dating site nigeria dating site filipina online dating christian dating websites christian dating australia
Delivered adult galleries
Date: 2017-04-14 12:43 am (UTC)http://hotpic.erolove.in/?entry-anastasia
young teens naturist 14 yo teen model young free bondage story teen girl 10 fucking www chicas desnudas en bikini com
Mod Protrude
Date: 2017-04-14 12:47 am (UTC)http://interracial.dating.porndairy.in/?stage.kiera
speed dating events free rich men dating sites legit free dating sites free marriage sites older dating com
Open matured galleries
Date: 2017-04-14 01:33 am (UTC)http://sexypic.erolove.in/?post.brianne
porn star legends mature asian upskirt movies pantie land.com amatuer thai porn sexy pre teen black girls
Full-grown galleries
Date: 2017-04-14 01:38 am (UTC)http://arab.sexy.girls.twiclub.in/?post-abigale
arrested town rizvi portraits telecharger
Communal pictures
Date: 2017-04-14 01:56 am (UTC)sexy lingerie outfits is my spouse cheating boys in dresses
http://sissytales.porndairy.in/?blog.parker
inns accommodation chastity lori maids head norwich chastity belt female my gf watch porn mens chastity underwear wedding gowns from china how islam
Pictures from social networks
Date: 2017-04-14 02:05 am (UTC)http://arab.egypt.adultnet.in/?entry-jailyn
fee ties iran liar malmo
Pictures from collective networks
Date: 2017-04-14 02:26 am (UTC)http://sunni.muslim.purplesphere.in/?post.aubrey
for دبي rabeh welsh proverbs