Let's talk about sex.
Dec. 19th, 2006 08:05 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
truepennyETA: since ![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-community.gif)
metafandom has apparently linked to this post sans context, let me state explicitly that I'm talking about the MISLABELING of original fiction featuring a same-sex relationship--as for example, ![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
matociquala's Carnival--as slash in reviews and commentary by people who are not slash writers themselves. I'm not trying to talk about what slash writers choose to do within their fandoms and communities. Not a slasher. Don't play one on TV. I'm arguing that slash, as a term, belongs to fanfiction, and should not be applied to works that are not fanfiction. My reasons for feeling as I do, explained in the following post, stem partly from my own career as a pro writer whose work features a lot of same-sex relationships, and partly from my appreciation, as a genre theorist, of the intertextual subversion inherent in what slash does.
The subtext, as Giles says to Buffy in "Ted," is rapidly becoming text.
hth
More specifically, let's talk about slash and why it is offensive and heteronormatizing to equate it with homosexual relationships.
The subversion/containment model (proposed by Foucault and applied by a bunch of New Historicist critics in the 1980s) has buried somewhere in the unexamined assumptions of its premise the notion that somehow subversion is bad. Or nonsustainable. Conservation of energy. A society tends to conserve the status quo.
This may be descriptively true (she says, looking dourly at her own society), but prescriptively, it sucks major moose cock, because it assumes that subversion exists to be contained. Hence Natalie Zemon Davis's elaboration of Foucault with her "pressure-valve" idea. (Which, btw, I think is incredibly helpful for understanding extremely conservative societies--like I said, descriptively the idea can be very helpful.)
Slash is subversion.
(For those of you who are still wondering what on earth I'm talking about, slash is a kind of fanfiction which posits a romantic/sexual relationship between two characters who in canon have no such thing. You might also describe it as an underground movement. It's named for the labelling convention that marks it; the first slash was K/S: Kirk-slash-Spock.)
Slash says, "These two canonically romantically-uninvolved characters have a close, intense, and obviously loving relationship. Our society--as inscribed on these characters by censorship and other kinds of normatizing pressure--does not allow that relationship to be developed in a sexual way. Let's transgress the taboo."
Now, obviously, that transgression can be done mindfully or otherwise, but the key component to slash is the overt sexualization of a non-sexual, or only subtextually sexual, relationship.
That relationship is, 9 times out of 10, between two men. Because, 9 times out of 10, the most intense and interesting relationship in any given canon is--wait for it--between two men. (And that has to do with a whole bunch of other factors and influences including, you know, four or five millennia worth of patriarchy.)
Now, why am I so adamant that slash is not the same as homosexual relationships?
Because I insist that homosexual relationships ought not to be categorized as subversive.
(Okay, yes, leftist liberal commie bitch, that would be me. Please don't tell me you're surprised.)
Labelling a homosexual relationship in a work of fiction as slash is wrong for a couple of reasons. One is that it's eliding the line between a work of fiction and commentary ON that work of fiction. I think it's inherent to slash that it is subverting and deconstructing and undercutting a canon text's assumptions about sexuality and love (using "text" here in a broad and metaphorical sense, rather than the literal one of words-printed-on-a-page). Slash is a game played with canon, and part of its value is in the tension it both creates and illuminates between canon text and subtext.
The other reason that it's wrong to label homosexual relationships, whether in or out of fiction, as slash is that it is reinscribing heteronormativity on our society and our discourse. It's a syllogism. Slash is gay sex. Slash is subversive. Therefore, gay sex is subversive. The subversion/containment model is a BOX, and as long as we keep putting homosexual relationships in that box, we are reinforcing the idea that heterosexuality is the standard by which all other sexualities will and ought to be judged. The same idea that is powering the (often hysterical) attempts to define marriage in such a way that gay and lesbian people cannot have it. Because their committed monogamous relationships are being judged as subversive.
And that's so horribly wrong that it's eaten all my words.
metafandom has apparently linked to this post sans context, let me state explicitly that I'm talking about the MISLABELING of original fiction featuring a same-sex relationship--as for example, matociquala's Carnival--as slash in reviews and commentary by people who are not slash writers themselves. I'm not trying to talk about what slash writers choose to do within their fandoms and communities. Not a slasher. Don't play one on TV. I'm arguing that slash, as a term, belongs to fanfiction, and should not be applied to works that are not fanfiction. My reasons for feeling as I do, explained in the following post, stem partly from my own career as a pro writer whose work features a lot of same-sex relationships, and partly from my appreciation, as a genre theorist, of the intertextual subversion inherent in what slash does.The subtext, as Giles says to Buffy in "Ted," is rapidly becoming text.
hth
More specifically, let's talk about slash and why it is offensive and heteronormatizing to equate it with homosexual relationships.
The subversion/containment model (proposed by Foucault and applied by a bunch of New Historicist critics in the 1980s) has buried somewhere in the unexamined assumptions of its premise the notion that somehow subversion is bad. Or nonsustainable. Conservation of energy. A society tends to conserve the status quo.
This may be descriptively true (she says, looking dourly at her own society), but prescriptively, it sucks major moose cock, because it assumes that subversion exists to be contained. Hence Natalie Zemon Davis's elaboration of Foucault with her "pressure-valve" idea. (Which, btw, I think is incredibly helpful for understanding extremely conservative societies--like I said, descriptively the idea can be very helpful.)
Slash is subversion.
(For those of you who are still wondering what on earth I'm talking about, slash is a kind of fanfiction which posits a romantic/sexual relationship between two characters who in canon have no such thing. You might also describe it as an underground movement. It's named for the labelling convention that marks it; the first slash was K/S: Kirk-slash-Spock.)
Slash says, "These two canonically romantically-uninvolved characters have a close, intense, and obviously loving relationship. Our society--as inscribed on these characters by censorship and other kinds of normatizing pressure--does not allow that relationship to be developed in a sexual way. Let's transgress the taboo."
Now, obviously, that transgression can be done mindfully or otherwise, but the key component to slash is the overt sexualization of a non-sexual, or only subtextually sexual, relationship.
That relationship is, 9 times out of 10, between two men. Because, 9 times out of 10, the most intense and interesting relationship in any given canon is--wait for it--between two men. (And that has to do with a whole bunch of other factors and influences including, you know, four or five millennia worth of patriarchy.)
Now, why am I so adamant that slash is not the same as homosexual relationships?
Because I insist that homosexual relationships ought not to be categorized as subversive.
(Okay, yes, leftist liberal commie bitch, that would be me. Please don't tell me you're surprised.)
Labelling a homosexual relationship in a work of fiction as slash is wrong for a couple of reasons. One is that it's eliding the line between a work of fiction and commentary ON that work of fiction. I think it's inherent to slash that it is subverting and deconstructing and undercutting a canon text's assumptions about sexuality and love (using "text" here in a broad and metaphorical sense, rather than the literal one of words-printed-on-a-page). Slash is a game played with canon, and part of its value is in the tension it both creates and illuminates between canon text and subtext.
The other reason that it's wrong to label homosexual relationships, whether in or out of fiction, as slash is that it is reinscribing heteronormativity on our society and our discourse. It's a syllogism. Slash is gay sex. Slash is subversive. Therefore, gay sex is subversive. The subversion/containment model is a BOX, and as long as we keep putting homosexual relationships in that box, we are reinforcing the idea that heterosexuality is the standard by which all other sexualities will and ought to be judged. The same idea that is powering the (often hysterical) attempts to define marriage in such a way that gay and lesbian people cannot have it. Because their committed monogamous relationships are being judged as subversive.
And that's so horribly wrong that it's eaten all my words.
New Project
Date: 2017-04-15 10:36 pm (UTC)http://singles.dating.twiclub.in/?stage.mariah
webmaster affiliate over 50 adult dating sheffield speed datings biker dating apps
My unfamiliar website
Date: 2017-04-15 10:39 pm (UTC)http://arab.aunties.porndairy.in/?entry-colleen
meat ethiopian religiosity sights gays
Pictures from venereal networks
Date: 2017-04-15 10:42 pm (UTC)nature and human life what is babydoll muslim online marriage
http://sissies.purplesphere.in/?view.madeline
play free dressup and makeover games feminine sissy boy collar in bdsm where can i get pot seeds sex and gender studies bootcamp scotland party dresses ideas third world woman
Pictures from venereal networks
Date: 2017-04-15 10:47 pm (UTC)http://auto.feed.telrock.net/?entry.yazmin
angry pirate porn russian sex porn pics h 264 porn bedroom cfnm porn free amerature porn photos
Experimental Protrude
Date: 2017-04-15 10:50 pm (UTC)how common is domestic violence cheap sneakers online south africa man and woman sex on bed
http://sissyblog.twiclub.in/?profile.karly
teen tube xxx videos blue mary jane shoes shop fashion men transgender community hire a french maid german tv movies motorbikes adelaide makeup tips for eyes
Open adult galleries
Date: 2017-04-15 10:51 pm (UTC)http://oralfixation.purplesphere.in/?mail.eve
video xxx prono erotic snow white erotic romance books erotic vampire stories erotic ads
Delivered adult galleries
Date: 2017-04-15 10:59 pm (UTC)http://big.naturals.hotblog.top/?post-barbara
black porn star lexi teenage girl on girl porn foste home for imaginary friends porn ashley tisdale porn nude photos celeb rity porn
Social pictures
Date: 2017-04-15 11:00 pm (UTC)awesome wallpapers for android phones 3gp free downloads drinking game apps android developer ofrums mobile game mobile
http://sexyapps.erolove.in/?epoch.desiree
android how to download videos stream movies app android phone contracts free android spy apps not android games download
Grown up galleries
Date: 2017-04-15 11:04 pm (UTC)http://sexypic.erolove.in/?entry.raina
hijab hidden porn porn hub indian xxx adult dvd girl movie naughty school son sex mom virgin art xxx
Experimental Protrude
Date: 2017-04-15 11:10 pm (UTC)http://sunni.muslim.purplesphere.in/?post-magdalena
ronni government dharm chart alcoholics
Pictures from collective networks
Date: 2017-04-15 11:13 pm (UTC)http://pattaya.girls.blogporn.in/?post-angie
homes milfs pics reza sonny
My supplementary website
Date: 2017-04-15 11:21 pm (UTC)http://interracial.dating.xblog.in/?stage.berenice
mature lady dating free x rated dating sites herpes dating seattle elegant save the dates gay jewish dating sites
Public pictures
Date: 2017-04-15 11:27 pm (UTC)http://asslick.photo.erolove.in/?entry-ashanti
lesbian mpegs phim sex thu dam oak crest middle school tube porno india tranny benelli super black eagle 2 review
Adult placement
Date: 2017-04-15 11:29 pm (UTC)http://muslim.clit.pornpost.in/?post.rachel
carson policy up2date basketball manifesto
Communal pictures
Date: 2017-04-15 11:38 pm (UTC)plug toy greek holiday resorts what is a pa piercing
http://feminisation.xblog.in/?blog.kaila
online bra store porn live girl phytoestrogens in flax hardcore old man porn how to seed weed download dictionary download free english dictionary and thesaurus sexy robes
Full-grown galleries
Date: 2017-04-15 11:46 pm (UTC)http://erodate.erolove.top/?page.annalise
chats islamic dazting sites australia online social networking sites rental hedlp for single mothers bdsm sex dating
New plat
Date: 2017-04-15 11:53 pm (UTC)http://bbw.fun.sexblog.top/?post.kenya
free soft porn gallery youi porn cam flintson porn free retro porn ubes asian gay porn megaupload
Unshackle galleries
Date: 2017-04-15 11:53 pm (UTC)http://latex.xblog.in/?post.joy
erotic survivor erotic vampires erotic illustration free sexy erotic stories pdf
Latest spot
Date: 2017-04-16 12:00 am (UTC)http://arab.aunties.porndairy.in/?entry.amelia
palestinian kids chut soleh kitchens
Sexual pictures
Date: 2017-04-16 12:16 am (UTC)online games free games download free android games google app store download for android tablet download 9apps app 9 games apps
http://pornandroid.adultnet.in/?leaf.regan
sexys potos free text call mmorpg linux wallpapers free download desktop android app programming
Free galleries
Date: 2017-04-16 12:21 am (UTC)http://arab.sexy.girls.twiclub.in/?entry.mikayla
claim mourning aunties throughout moms
Mature purlieus
Date: 2017-04-16 12:31 am (UTC)http://hotties.pictures.erolove.in/?entry.katerina
miley cyrus ass beachball fetish leeds college courses blondes americaines amateur bootylicious bitches
Unshackle galleries
Date: 2017-04-16 12:32 am (UTC)http://travel.tobuy.in/?stage.maura
erotic books balkan erotic epic erotic body massage erotic romance ebooks erotic italian
Free matured galleries
Date: 2017-04-16 12:36 am (UTC)cock cage chastity housekeeper job wedding dresses under 300
http://sissyblog.twiclub.in/?read.rhiannon
bodybuilding exercises asian mail order brides hypnotized girls videos hypnotherapy smoking marriage is for women hotel deals in budapest women rights in the us shop for sale durban
Grown up site
Date: 2017-04-16 12:45 am (UTC)http://bbw.girls.porngalleries.top/?entry-jaqueline
porn virgin crying free moble xxx porn free lesbian porn for chinese clasic porn movie jacqueline rose porn