There is a difference between "intertextual" and "derivative."
Yes, but they're overlapping, in the sense that in both cases, "canon" assumes something besides real life. I do think "Brokeback Mountain is slashing the cowboy myth" is a perfectly valid statement if used in a context where people know what slash means. (It's not even all that different from what non-fannish reviewers are saying, using different words.)
Also, while I realize that you disagree with me passionately, and I don't deny your right to do so, kindly refrain from patronizing me.
You're right, I was unnecessarily snarky. There used to be a time when I could participate in online discussions without taking things to heart, but somehow it seems I can't, lately. I'm sorry.
OTOH, even back then I was a bit of a bitch, so maybe the difference is just that now I sometimes feel guilty about it.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
momijizukamori
no subject
Date: 2006-12-22 06:31 pm (UTC)Yes, but they're overlapping, in the sense that in both cases, "canon" assumes something besides real life. I do think "Brokeback Mountain is slashing the cowboy myth" is a perfectly valid statement if used in a context where people know what slash means. (It's not even all that different from what non-fannish reviewers are saying, using different words.)
Also, while I realize that you disagree with me passionately, and I don't deny your right to do so, kindly refrain from patronizing me.
You're right, I was unnecessarily snarky. There used to be a time when I could participate in online discussions without taking things to heart, but somehow it seems I can't, lately. I'm sorry.
OTOH, even back then I was a bit of a bitch, so maybe the difference is just that now I sometimes feel guilty about it.