UBC: Lizzie Borden
Apr. 21st, 2011 05:32 pmBrown, Arnold R. Lizzie Borden: The Legend, the Truth, the Final Chapter. Nashville, TN: Rutledge Hill Press, 1991. [library]
All things considered, this was probably not the best place to start reading about Lizzie Borden.
( behind the cut, a fairly detailed critique )
I don't know that Arnold Brown is wrong, but he fails utterly to persuade me that he is right. Mostly, he persuades me that he is a man with a hobby horse.
If Arnold Brown has represented himself correctly, then it is true that he had access to primary sources that were previously unavailable. Does anyone know of any trustworthy books on the Borden murders written after 1991? I'll also gladly take opinions of pre-1991 books and whether any of them are worth pursuing, but if Brown really did have new primary sources, I'd like to know what other scholars have made of them.
All things considered, this was probably not the best place to start reading about Lizzie Borden.
( behind the cut, a fairly detailed critique )
I don't know that Arnold Brown is wrong, but he fails utterly to persuade me that he is right. Mostly, he persuades me that he is a man with a hobby horse.
If Arnold Brown has represented himself correctly, then it is true that he had access to primary sources that were previously unavailable. Does anyone know of any trustworthy books on the Borden murders written after 1991? I'll also gladly take opinions of pre-1991 books and whether any of them are worth pursuing, but if Brown really did have new primary sources, I'd like to know what other scholars have made of them.